Video Briefing

Nomad Capitalist: My Bad Real Estate Deal

Feb 17, 2023Video Briefing14:48Watch on YouTube

Investing in overseas real‑estate can still be profitable even when a country’s currency weakens, provided the purchase is tied to solid fundamentals such as residency or citizenship programs, location quality, and long‑term economic trends.

Currency timing and hedging

  • In 2019 the Colombian peso traded around 3,500 COP per USD; by 2024 it averaged ≈4,000 COP and peaked near 4,700 COP.
  • Buyers can mitigate exchange‑rate risk by holding foreign currency in accounts that allow on‑demand conversion (e.g., Wise, private‑bank foreign‑currency accounts, or local brokerage accounts).
  • By keeping cash ready at a multi‑year low, an investor can lock in the original purchase price even if the local currency later depreciates.

Residency and citizenship incentives

  • Colombia once offered a permanent‑residence‑by‑investment program: investing the equivalent of 650 monthly minimum wages in property granted immediate permanent residency, bypassing the 180‑day‑per‑year temporary‑residence requirement.
  • The program has since been discontinued; waiting for a higher exchange rate would have forfeited the residency benefit.
  • Similar “golden‑visa” schemes exist in Turkey (path to citizenship) and were recently cancelled in Paraguay, illustrating that these incentives can be altered or removed with little notice.
  • Permanent residency can provide pandemic‑related travel exemptions, easier cross‑border movement, and a stepping stone toward full citizenship.

Selecting the right property

Criterion Why it matters
Prime neighborhood with sustained international demand (e.g., Bogotá’s upscale districts, Istanbul’s historic quarters) Higher likelihood of price resilience and rental demand
Low carrying costs (maintenance, security, utilities) Improves net cash flow and reduces the need for high rental yields
Purpose‑built for residence, not short‑term Airbnb Avoids frequent tenant turnover, cleaning logistics, and additional local tax filings
Infrastructure and services (reliable utilities, security, reputable building management) Enhances long‑term livability and resale appeal

Yield performance

  • Istanbul property: ~14 % annual return over two years, after accounting for Turkish inflation and currency depreciation.
  • Bogotá property: ~9 % nominal yield in USD terms, despite a falling peso, due to strong neighborhood fundamentals and limited local mortgage pressure.
  • Malaysia example: a property purchased at a currency low later lost 15‑20 % in value, illustrating the risk of markets with oversupply and limited appreciation potential.

Risks and program volatility

  • Policy changes: Golden‑visa or permanent‑residence programs can be tightened, suspended, or eliminated (e.g., Paraguay’s cancellation).
  • Political shifts: Elections may trigger short‑term market sentiment, but in Bogotá recent left‑wing leadership has not led to mass sell‑offs; inventory listings have actually declined.
  • Currency swings: Depreciation can erode local‑currency gains, but hedging strategies and the USD‑denominated value of the asset can offset this.
  • Local tax compliance: Owning rental property may trigger local tax filings; the administrative burden should be factored into the investment decision.

Comparative market insights

  • Colombia: Property prices around $1,600 USD per m²; visa‑free travel to the UK now available for Colombian passport holders, enhancing the country’s global mobility profile.
  • Turkey: Higher price per m² in premium Istanbul neighborhoods, but strong rental demand and a clear citizenship pathway.
  • Malaysia: Abundant new supply, modest appreciation, and limited upside for investors focused on capital growth.
  • Paraguay: Previously easy permanent‑residence route now suspended, highlighting the need for continual program monitoring.

Strategic takeaways

  • Allocate only a single‑digit percentage of net worth to lifestyle‑oriented overseas property; keep the bulk of the portfolio diversified in traditional assets.
  • Prioritize properties that deliver both residency benefits and solid fundamentals, rather than chasing the highest short‑term yields.
  • Conduct thorough research and development before purchase: understand local closing procedures, contract language, and tax obligations.
  • View the property as a base for market intelligence—living in the region can reveal business opportunities and investment trends not visible from afar.

By focusing on location quality, leveraging residency programs before they disappear, and managing currency exposure, investors can turn what appears to be a “bad deal” into a long‑term asset that supports both lifestyle flexibility and portfolio diversification.